Skip to content
NoetaINDEPENDENT STUDY LIBRARY

HOME OFFICE ยท The UK government, the law and your role

Devolved administrations

12 questions in this part of the Life in the UK Test bank. Every answer below is the one the bank holds, and the document under each question is where it was written from. They are written from those documents; they are not the questions of the real test, which are not published.

Practise the whole bank in the browserThe same bank as an Android app, on Google Play

All 12 questions

  1. 1. Devolved administrationsgov-02

    Which Act of Parliament created the Scottish Parliament?

    • AThe Scotland Act 1998Answer
    • BThe Act of Union 1707
    • CThe Government of Wales Act 1998
    • DThe Human Rights Act 1998

    Devolution came in 1998, and the Scotland Act of that year opens by simply stating that there shall be a Scottish Parliament. The 1707 union did the opposite - it ended the old Scottish Parliament by merging the two kingdoms. The Government of Wales Act is the parallel statute for Wales, and the Human Rights Act deals with rights, not devolution.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/section/1

  2. 2. Devolved administrationsgov-132

    Under the Scotland Act 1998, which of these is a reserved matter that the Scottish Parliament cannot legislate on?

    • ASchool education in Scotland
    • BThe defence of the realmAnswer
    • CThe health service in Scotland
    • DScots criminal law

    Schedule 5 to the Act lists the matters kept at Westminster, and the defence of the realm, together with the armed forces, is one of them. Health, school education and Scots criminal law were not reserved, which is why Scotland runs its own health service and its own courts. The trap is to assume that anything felt to be national must automatically be reserved.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/schedule/5

  3. 3. Devolved administrationsgov-133

    What are the members of the Welsh legislature called under the Government of Wales Act 2006 as it now stands?

    • AAssembly Members
    • BMembers of the SeneddAnswer
    • CMembers of Parliament for Wales
    • DWelsh Ministers

    The Act now provides that they are known as Members of the Senedd, or Aelodau o'r Senedd in Welsh. Assembly Members is the tempting answer, because that was the title until the body was renamed, and Welsh Ministers is something else again: those are the members of the Welsh Government, not of the legislature.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/32/section/1

  4. 4. Devolved administrationsgov-134

    Under the Northern Ireland Act 1998, how is the First Minister of Northern Ireland chosen after an Assembly election?

    • ABy a majority vote of all the members of the Assembly
    • BBy appointment by the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland
    • CNominated by the largest party of the largest political designationAnswer
    • DBy the party that leads the UK Government at Westminster

    The Act gives the nomination to the nominating officer of the largest political party of the largest political designation, and the deputy First Minister is nominated by the second largest designation. There is no straight majority vote of the Assembly, and London does not appoint: the two offices are built to be held jointly across the two communities.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/47/section/16A

  5. 5. Devolved administrationsgov-141

    In the Northern Ireland Assembly, what is the effect of a petition of concern on a vote?

    • AThe vote then requires cross community supportAnswer
    • BThe vote is postponed to the next Assembly term
    • CThe matter is referred to the UK Parliament instead
    • DThe vote needs a two thirds majority of all members

    A petition of concern is a brake built into the Belfast arrangements. Once thirty members present it and thirty confirm it the day after the consideration period, the matter can no longer be carried by a simple majority: it needs support across the unionist and nationalist designations. The confirmation step does delay the vote by a day, but nothing is sent elsewhere and no fixed fraction of the whole chamber is set.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/47/section/42

  6. 6. Devolved administrationsgov-142

    Under the Scotland Act 2016, how could the Scottish Parliament be abolished?

    • AOnly after the people of Scotland vote for that in a referendumAnswer
    • BBy a simple majority vote in the Scottish Parliament itself
    • CIt cannot be abolished under any circumstances
    • DBy a ruling of the Supreme Court

    The 2016 Act wrote permanence into the statute book: the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government are described as a permanent part of the constitutional arrangements of the United Kingdom, and the Act then says plainly that they are not to be abolished unless the people of Scotland decide so in a referendum. Abolition is not impossible, then. It was simply taken out of the hands of politicians and courts.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2016/11/section/1

  7. 7. Devolved administrationsgov-143

    The Scotland Act records a convention about Westminster legislating on devolved matters. What does it say?

    • AIt will not normally do so without consent from EdinburghAnswer
    • BIt may do so freely, since devolution changed nothing
    • CIt may do so only after a Scotland wide referendum
    • DIt may never do so once a matter has been devolved

    This is the Sewel convention, added to the Act in 2016 and worded carefully. Westminster keeps the legal power in full, so the third and fourth answers are too strong, but it accepts that it will not normally legislate on devolved matters without consent from Edinburgh. The single word normally is what makes this a convention rather than a rule a court could enforce.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/section/28

  8. 8. Devolved administrationsgov-144

    In the Government of Wales Act 2006, which Welsh title belongs to the First Minister?

    • APrif WeinidogAnswer
    • BCwnsler Cyffredinol
    • CGweinidogion Cymru
    • DLlywodraeth Cymru

    The Act lists the members of the Welsh Government in both languages side by side, so the Welsh titles can be read straight off it. The First Minister appears as Prif Weinidog. The other three are real terms from the same statute but belong elsewhere: Gweinidogion Cymru is the plural title for the Welsh Ministers as a group, Cwnsler Cyffredinol is the Counsel General, its senior law officer, and Llywodraeth Cymru names the Welsh administration as a whole rather than any person.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/32/section/45

  9. 9. Devolved administrationsgov-46

    What happens to a provision of an Act of the Scottish Parliament that falls outside its legislative competence, for example because it concerns a reserved matter?

    • AThat provision is not lawAnswer
    • BIt takes effect until Westminster repeals it
    • CIt takes effect once a UK minister approves it
    • DNothing, because the Scottish Parliament has unlimited competence

    Devolution handed over defined powers rather than all of them, so an Act that strays beyond the boundary simply has no legal force in that part. It is not a valid law awaiting cancellation or approval from London. Reserved matters, such as defence, stay with the UK Parliament.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/section/29

  10. 10. Devolved administrationsgov-47

    How does a Bill passed by the Northern Ireland Assembly become an Act?

    • AIt becomes an Act the moment the Assembly votes for it
    • BIt must also pass the House of Commons
    • CIt must receive Royal AssentAnswer
    • DIt must be approved in a referendum

    Devolved legislation follows the same last step as legislation at Westminster: the Assembly passes the Bill and Royal Assent turns it into an Act. It does not travel to the Commons for a second passage, which is the point of devolving law making in the first place.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/47/section/5

  11. 11. Devolved administrationsgov-85

    Does the Government of Wales Act 2006, which lets the Senedd make its own Acts, take away the UK Parliament's power to legislate for Wales?

    • AYes, on any subject once the Senedd has legislated on it
    • BNo, the Act does not affect that powerAnswer
    • CYes, on every subject from the day the Senedd was created
    • DOnly if the Supreme Court agrees in each case

    The Act states that this part of it does not affect the power of the UK Parliament to make laws for Wales, so the answer is no, the Act does not affect that power, although by convention Parliament does not normally legislate on devolved matters without the Senedd's consent. Yes, on any subject once the Senedd has legislated on it is the tempting answer, because in practice Westminster does hold back, but a convention of restraint is not the same as losing the power. The Supreme Court rules on whether Senedd legislation is within competence rather than licensing Westminster.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/32/section/107

  12. 12. Devolved administrationsgov-86

    Under the Scotland Act 1998, what are the members of the Scottish Government called collectively?

    • AThe Scottish Cabinet
    • BThe Scottish Executive Council
    • CThe Scottish MinistersAnswer
    • DThe Members of the Scottish Parliament

    The Act provides that the members of the Scottish Government are referred to collectively as the Scottish Ministers, a phrase that then appears throughout Scottish legislation. The Members of the Scottish Parliament is the tempting answer, because ministers are drawn from that Parliament, but the legislature and the government it supports are different bodies. The Scottish Cabinet is an informal description, and the Scottish Executive Council is not a statutory term.

    Sourcehttps://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/46/section/44

Other parts of the Life in the UK Test